1516 New York Avenue, 7 Bedrooms, 5 Baths, Sleeps 16

Experience the pinnacle of coastal luxury at 1516 New York Avenue, a masterfully renovated estate situated in the tranquil and prestigious Poverty Beach neighborhood of Cape May. This high-end retreat is designed for the discerning traveler, offering seven spacious bedrooms and a thoughtful layout that comfortably accommodates up to 16 guests. Just two blocks from the pristine ocean beaches and the lush 100-acre wildlife sanctuary, this home serves as a private sanctuary where modern sophistication meets the timeless charm of the Jersey Shore.

The heart of the home is found on the expansive third level, easily accessible via the private elevator that services all three floors. This sun-drenched, open-concept space features a gourmet kitchen, a cozy breakfast nook, and a grand living area anchored by a double gas fireplace. Also located on this top floor is the primary master suite, a true haven of relaxation featuring its own double-sided gas fireplace and a spa-like ensuite bathroom complete with a soaking tub and walk-in shower. Every inch of this level was meticulously designed by the owners to encourage effortless entertaining and shared memories against a backdrop of coastal breezes.

Thoughtful consideration was given to every guests comfort, particularly on the first and second floors. The first floor features a secondary master bedroom specifically designed for accessibility and peace of mind, making it ideal for multi-generational families. This room offers a view of the pool, a private gas fireplace, and a convenient coffee bar with a microwave, while a beautiful bathroom with a walk-in shower is located just across the hallway.

The second floor houses two full bathrooms and the remaining five bedrooms, which are notably spacious and intentionally decorated to avoid the feeling of crowded quarters. Among them is an oversized suite that rivals the size of two standard rooms, featuring a king bed and a queen-size pull-out sofa for flexible sleeping arrangements. Out of the remaining four bedrooms on the second floor, three bedrooms each have one queen bed, and the fourth bedroom has a double bed with pullout single trundle.

The outdoor and wellness amenities truly set this property apart as one of the finest rentals in Cape May. For the 2026 season, guests can enjoy a brand-new inground swimming pool and an integrated hot tub, complemented by a professional-grade outdoor kitchen and a covered dining area on the deck. After a day at the beach, you can retreat indoors to the private sauna room for a detoxifying session. Whether you are hosting a summer barbecue or enjoying a quiet morning by the pool, this home offers an unparalleled blend of luxury and comfort.